Beyond the politics of positionality: deconstruction and feminism

Original Articles

Beyond the politics of positionality: deconstruction and feminism

Published in: South African Journal of Philosophy
Volume 17 , issue 4 , 1998 , pages: 377–394
DOI: 10.1080/02580136.1998.10878173
Author(s): Elly Holm Department of Philosophy, South Africa , Paul Cilliers Department of Philosophy, South Africa

Abstract

The article commences with a discussion of Derrida's alleged anti-feminist position. We argue that, given his distinction between ‘reactive’ and ‘maverick’ feminism, this is an over-simplification. A correlation is drawn between the latter form of feminism and deconstruction by showing that both maintain a relation to the ‘beyond’ of the established logocentric system. The second section of the article deals with the placing of woman in Derrida's Spurs. It is shown that Derrida affirms Nietzsche's idea of the ‘Dionysiac woman’ who is, like the maverick feminist, not totally determined within the phallogocentric system. Woman, in Derrida's reading, becomes that which is not fully determinable. We conclude that this undecidability, rather than hindering its political activity, helps feminism in dealing with the diversities within the movement.

Get new issue alerts for South African Journal of Philosophy